Super guarantee and payroll risks
One of the least discussed — and most poorly understood — risks of novated leasing is how your employer calculates super guarantee (SG) i.e. the minimum employer superannuation contribution, currently 12% of your ordinary time earnings (renamed qualifying earnings from 1 July 2026 under Payday Super).
Most people assume that:
“Surely my employer has to pay super on my original salary, right?”
Often yes. But not always. And importantly: they don’t have to.
This page explains why, with direct reference to the ATO’s own guidance.
The common belief: “A novated lease can’t reduce my SG”
A commonly cited argument goes like this:
“I remember the government closing a loophole so that super has to be calculated on pre-salary-sacrifice income. I read something along those lines. So surely they have to pay super on the figure before the novated lease!”
This belief is only partially correct.
It comes from ATO Guidance Note GN 2020/1, which did close a loophole — but only for salary sacrifice into super.
It did not close the loophole for novated leases or other non-super salary sacrifice arrangements.
What GN 2020/1 actually says
The key sentence people usually quote is this one (GN 2020/1):
”From 1 January 2020, you calculate the minimum amount of super guarantee on the employee’s OTE base. This is the sum of the employee’s OTE and any OTE amounts they sacrifice in return for super contributions.”
That part is correct.
However, the very same document goes on to say (emphasis mine):
“Calculation of super guarantee relating to other sacrificed amounts (such as salary sacrifice arrangements for cars, property or expense payments) are not affected by these changes.”
In other words:
- Salary sacrificed into super → must be added back for SG calculation
- Salary sacrificed into novated leases → does not have to be added back
This is not interpretation. This is the ATO’s own wording.
The Sharon example (straight from GN 2020/1)
GN 2020/1 then gives an explicit worked example that removes any ambiguity.
Sharon has a weekly wage of $2,000, which is entirely OTE.
She sacrifices:
- $300 per week into super, and
- $200 per week towards a novated car lease.
Before 1 January 2020
- Employer calculated SG on $1,500 ($2,000 − $500)
- SG = $1,500 × 9.5% = $142.50 1
From 1 January 2020
- Salary sacrificed into super must be added back
- Salary sacrificed into novated lease does not
Sharon’s OTE base becomes:
- $1,500 (post-sacrifice wage)
- plus $300 (super sacrifice)
- = $1,800
SG obligation:
- $1,800 × 9.5% = $171 1
Notice what did not get added back:
- The $200 novated lease sacrifice.
The ATO could not have been clearer.
Source: GN 2020/1
https://www.ato.gov.au/law/view/pdf/gdn/gdn2020-001.pdf
What the legislation says: s15A, now s10A(1)(h)
GN 2020/1 is guidance. The rule itself sits in the Superannuation Guarantee (Administration) Act 1992, and it rests on a narrow, defined meaning of “salary sacrifice”.
1 January 2020 to 30 June 2026: section 15A
The 2020 change inserted section 15A, which defined a salary sacrifice arrangement for SG purposes:
15A(1) An arrangement under which a contribution is, or is to be, made to a complying superannuation fund or an RSA by an employer for the benefit of an employee is a salary sacrifice arrangement if the employee agreed:
(a) for the contribution to be made; and
(b) in return, for either or both of the following amounts to be reduced (including to nil):
(i) the ordinary time earnings of the employee;
(ii) the salary or wages of the employee.
In everyday language, “salary sacrifice” covers any pre-tax deduction, including a novated lease. In the SG Act it only means giving up salary in return for a super contribution. Only those amounts had to be added back to the OTE base. A novated lease deduction was never a “salary sacrifice arrangement” in this sense, which is why the Sharon example leaves the $200 out.
From 1 July 2026: section 10A(1)(h)
Payday Super (Treasury Laws Amendment (Payday Superannuation) Act 2025) repealed section 15A and replaced the OTE base with qualifying earnings, defined in section 10A. The salary sacrifice rule moved into paragraph 10A(1)(h), which counts:
10A(1)(h) if under an arrangement the person agreed for:
(i) a contribution to be made to a complying superannuation fund or an RSA for the benefit of the person by the person’s employer; and
(ii) in return, for the reduction (including to nil) of one or more amounts of a kind described in paragraphs (a) to (g) of this subsection but not in subsection (3) of this section;an amount equal to the total of those reductions.
The Act no longer has a stand-alone definition of “salary sacrifice arrangement”, but the essence is unchanged: salary given up only counts towards the SG base if it was given up in return for a super contribution. Salary sacrificed into a novated lease is not paid to you, so it falls outside paragraphs (a) to (g), and it is not exchanged for a super contribution, so paragraph (h) does not add it back.
Sources: SG Act as in force from 1 July 2026 (legislation.gov.au); ATO: What payments are qualifying earnings
What this means in practice
Legally, both before and after Payday Super:
- Employers must calculate SG on pre-sacrifice income for salary sacrificed into super
- Employers may calculate SG on post-novated-lease income for novated leases
There is no requirement for them to add novated lease amounts back.
What most employers actually do
In practice:
- Most employers still pay SG on your pre-novated-lease salary, which is beneficial for employees
- However, some employers do not
Based on:
- repeated reports in forums and comment threads, and
- a poll I previously ran in an EV Facebook group,
around ~5% of respondents reported that their employer calculates SG on post-novated-lease income.
This is a minority, but with significant impact.
Why this matters financially
If your employer calculates SG on post-NL income:
- your compulsory super contribution is lower
- the impact compounds over decades
- the loss can easily exceed $1,000+ per year.
This potential loss is rarely disclosed clearly in novated lease marketing.
This is a payroll risk, not a novated lease feature
To be clear:
- this is not caused by novated leasing itself
- this is a payroll policy choice made by your employer
Two employees on identical leases can have different outcomes depending purely on payroll implementation.
What you should do before signing
Before committing to a novated lease, ask payroll explicitly:
“Is my super guarantee calculated on my pre-novated-lease salary, or post-novated-lease salary?”
If you don’t get a clear written answer, assume nothing.
Key takeaway
If you remember nothing else:
While most employers pay the same amount of super after novated lease, a minority reduce their super contribution due to the use of post-NL income figure in the calculation.
Most employers still do the “right thing” for employees.
But legally, they don’t have to — and some don’t.
That makes this a real, if uncommon, risk worth understanding before you sign.
Payday Super — the new regime requiring employers to remit super contributions within days of each payday rather than quarterly — took effect from 1 July 2026. It came to my attention that this new policy has led to some employers switching their calculation to post-novated-lease income, even when it was previously calculated on pre-NL income. If this happened to you, you permanently lose 12% of your sacrificed amount — which can add up to $10,000+ over the life of an EV novated lease.
Has Payday Super actually forced this? No. Payday Super repealed section 15A, but moved the same rule into the new “qualifying earnings” definition at section 10A(1)(h) (explained above). Only salary given up in return for a super contribution is added back; non-super sacrifice (novated leases, laptops, and similar arrangements) is still excluded from the SG minimum — the same GN 2020/1 rule, in substance unchanged. Employers could always calculate SG on your post-NL figure; most simply chose to keep the pre-NL figure and “do the right thing.” Nothing about Payday Super changed that choice either way.
So if your super has dropped since 1 July 2026, it’s most likely one of two things: (1) payroll was reconfigured for Payday Super and the new software defaulted to excluding the novated lease portion — an implementation issue rather than a deliberate policy change, or (2) your employer used the changeover as cover to quietly drop to the legal minimum — exactly the risk this page has always described, just newly triggered by an unrelated administrative change.
Before you accept “Payday Super made us do it”: check your award or Enterprise Bargaining Agreement (EBA) first. If it requires super on your total remuneration or pre-sacrifice salary, your pre-NL super is a contractual entitlement, not goodwill — and dropping it is a breach of that agreement regardless of Payday Super. That’s your strongest ground if you need to push back.
Do this now if your new-financial-year super looks lower:
- Ask payroll: “What salary base are you now calculating my super guarantee on?”
- Ask: “Does my award/EBA require super on my pre-sacrifice salary?”
- If yes to #2: they owe you the difference — raise it in writing.
Share this with anyone you know on a novated lease — this is an easy one to miss until a full financial year of contributions has already gone through.
Footnotes
This calculator and guide are built and continuously maintained as an independent project.
If it has helped you think more clearly, avoid a costly mistake, or saved you meaningful money, you're welcome to support its ongoing maintenance and improvements:
- Buying me a cuppa ☕ to help cover hosting, development time, and future improvements, or
- Using this Tesla referral link for a $350 discount if you're ordering a Tesla.
I'm backing Dr Michael Keane's fight for salary packaging transparency
Workplaces with an exclusive salary packaging provider tend to have noticeably higher effective interest rates on novated leases — yet the commercial terms behind these exclusive arrangements are rarely disclosed to employees.
Dr Michael Keane, a Melbourne anaesthetist, is taking a Victorian health service to the Victorian Supreme Court to obtain the unredacted contract between the hospital and its exclusive salary packaging provider. The unredacted version may shed light on alleged sign-on fees associated with exclusive access to hospital employees — an arrangement whose financial terms employees are rarely privy to.
To date, Dr Keane has personally spent around $15,700 pursuing this case, with further legal costs anticipated. I believe this matters to anyone in a workplace with an exclusive provider. If you agree, consider supporting his
GoFundMe.